Hrm.
Well, I'll list the pelts/antlers that aren't used much, from what I can tell.
Pelts:
-Kirin
-Peacock
-Red one-striped pelt
-"Autumn" pelt (orange with brown stripes)

Antlers:
-Golden butterfly
-Bell
-Carnival (with feathers)
-Those strange brown and thin antlers that curve (xD)
-Secretary bird antlers (spiky & white)
-Orca antlers
-Beluga antlers (to a degree)

I think that the orca or beluga antlers would work best, perhaps with the autumn pelt. ^^'

They're the short, stubby black ones. ^^